Taylor 5557 Body Fat Analyzer and Scale with Unique Glass Platform
|
List Price: Category: Health Care See more product details |
|---|
(Click here)
Customer Reviews of Taylor 5557 Body Fat Analyzer and Scale with Unique Glass Platform
Customer Review: Not worth the nice look
Summary: 2 Stars
I paid $45 for this aesthetically pleasing scale. Sure it looks nice, but if it doesn't do its job, it's not much of an accessory for the bathroom.
It took me a while to figure out how the scale works. There are a lot of beeps involved. Essentially, to program your info, you start by pressing
the mode button, adjust your height, press mode, adjust your age, press mode, select your gender, press mode, select between normal and athlete, press mode and you will hear a beep to confirm. Then to store, press either the up button for memory #s 1,3 and 5 or the down button for #s 2,4 and 6, press mode and there will be another beep to confirm.
Still with me? If you just want your weight, you just step on the scale, but if you want to get your body fat and water %, you must press the up or down button to find your memory #, then press mode and wait for the beep before you step on the scale.
Now I don't know about you, but this procedure is a lot more cumbersome than any other scale I owned. So fine, I've now figured out how to work the thing. Getting even somewhat accurate results are another thing.
When I stepped on the scale, I would sometimes be surprised by the weight. I didn't think I could gain 7 pounds in one day (I eat very healthy and my weight range is usually between 3-4 pounds). But if you step on the scale again, like some other digital scales, it seems to remember your last weight and won't give you your real weight. So I have to put some other object on it to get a reading and then the scale resets. I step on the scale again and my weight is now 6 pounds less than the original reading!
The body water % didn't fluctuate too much and the body fat % was 3% higher than the reading on the last scale I owned (Conair Thinner brand).
All in all, I am returning this scale and going back to the drawing board in finding something that is even the least bit accurate.
Customer Review: Not Accurate
Summary: 2 Stars
Agreed with a couple of the other reviews...this scale is not accurate!
I have the scale on a flat surface, but when just stepping on it for a weight reading, it fluctuates rapidly WAY over what I wheigh...I have to try to stand perfectly still to get it to settle on a weight, but it is typically 50 pounds over my normal weight. If I step on it 2-4 more times, it will eventually give me a result that is at least in the right area...but I can't trust it at this point.
I had no problems with the BF portion of it, other than it is a pain to get down on the floor to push the buttons.
It is asthetically pleaseing, but for the cost, I don't think the weight function works right. I intend to return this one.
Customer Review: not accurate
Summary: 2 Stars
pretty but not accurate. can be 5 pounds different day to day, or even am to pm. body fat can flucuate 5% in one day which is not normal. BIA is not the gold standard in body fat measurement, which means it has a larger margin of error, but at least the scale could be accurate. it's not. i'm returning this item.Customer Review: Just not accurate
Summary: 2 Stars
Inaccurate. The same issues that plague cheaper scales. I might accept this if it was a $20 scale, but it isn't. A scale this price should at least be able to produce accurate weight readings.
Do not buy if you can find something comparable with good accuracy.